How Jeep Grand Cherokee failed the evasive maneuver test

2012-07-10 | Mattias Rabe

Teknikens Värld’s evasive maneuver test, also known as moose test, with the Jeep Grand Cherokee quickly became a world scoop. Here is how we test all cars in the evasive maneuver test, including the Grand Cherokee which was about to roll over.

For Swedish version, click here.

Also watch the movie Jeep Grand Cherokee moose test failure – the full story on film.

Click image to enlarge.
Graphic illustrating the moose test track.

Teknikens Värld have tested cars since 1948. As the car became more common, and soon a property of every household, our tests became more investigatory. In the 1970s, we introduced what is popularly known as the moose test, an avoidance maneuver test that is run on a carefully set track (see graphics). It simulates an emergency situation on the road where an obstacle (such as a moose, a child, another vehicle or anything equivalent) suddenly appears in front of the car. A situation where the driver is forced to swerve onto the opposite side of the road and then back to the travel-direction side to avoid an accident.
The moose test became famous in 1997 when the first generation Mercedes A-Class (W168) overturned in Teknikens Värld’s moose test. Mercedes admitted – after first denying the problem – that the car had deficiencies and recalled cars already sold. Mercedes fitted the A-Class with electronic stability control (ESC/ESP) and changed chassis settings.
Today, the moose test is used by many car manufacturers in the development of a new model.
Teknikens Värld moose tests hundreds of cars every year, which means that after almost 40 years of moose testing a huge amount of cars have passed our evasive maneuver test. With the today’s technology, such as electronic stability systems and in some cases anti-rollover systems, most cars perform good in our moose test. Sometimes cars do not perform good, as was the case of the Mercedes A-Class in 1997, the Toyota Hilux in 2007 (movie here), the Skoda Superb in 2010 and now – the Jeep Grand Cherokee.

The moose test with the Jeep Grand Cherokee was conducted – as always in the moose test – in accordance to the following parameters, to the smallest detail:

In every performed moose test with Jeep Grand Cherokee, the car either went up on two wheels and was close to overturning or the tires were pried off the rims due to the heavy forces. When we performed the moose test with Chrysler/Fiat present the car manufacturer’s representatives on site provided the loading of the car. Then the tires were pried off the rims instead of going up on two wheels like before. A total of seven times, the tires were pried off the wheels, a very serious error that we have only seen once before – with Skoda Superb in 2010 (see image). When a tire is pried off the wheel the rim’s edge is exposed, which get stuck in the asphalt and may lead to a snatch and a roll over.
Then, in 2010, Skoda admitted that the Superb was certified with too low tire pressure and too high maximum load capacity, and then sent out new recommendations and vehicle information.

We used Volkswagen Touareg and Volvo XC90 as reference cars in this particular moose test. These two cars were also evasive maneuver tested, following the exact same principles as mentioned above: with full load, correct tire pressure and so on. Both the Touareg and the XC90 can handle about 43.5 mph (70 km/h) with no signs of roll over tendencies. The ESP systems work effectively in these cars, which is clearly noticeable in the evasive maneuvers. In the Jeep Grand Cherokee we notice almost no engagement at all from the ESP system.
Notably, the Jeep Grand Cherokee of the previous generation was moose tested by Teknikens Värld in 2005 and passed 42 mph (67 km/h) without any problems. It worked almost as well as the Volvo XC90, which was tested at the same time.
In 2005 we wrote following:
”The vehicle stability control system with integrated anti-roll system is not among the finest calibrated on the market. But the car does its job, it stops the rollover tendency, braking with the front wheels and understeers out of the track.”
It is thus obvious that the new Grand Cherokee lacks something that the previous generation had.

Here you can watch Teknikens Värld’s video where the latest generation Jeep Grand Cherokee goes up on two wheels and almost rolls over.

Relaterade inlägg

Många underskattar kostnaden att äga en bil

Många underskattar kostnaden att äga en bil

Ny undersökningar visar: Många som köper bil vet inte vad den kostar att äga över tid. Det visar en ny Sifo-undersökning från KVD Bilpriser, som jämfört ägandekostnaden för olika modeller och vad svenska folket tror att det kostar att äga en bil. Enligt undersökningen tror de flesta att en tre år gammal begagnad bil kostar […]

Trendbrott: nu backar försäljningen av begagnade bilar

Trendbrott: nu backar försäljningen av begagnade bilar

För första gången på fem år minskar nu försäljningen av begagnade bilar. Under andra kvartalet 2017 tappade försäljningen med 1,5 procent, jämfört med året innan. Bakom tappet står en minskad försäljning av bilar från privatpersoner. Det visar ny statistik från KVD Bilpriser. Under andra kvartalet 2017 såldes 307 125 begagnade bilar vilket är en minskning […]

Köpa begagnad hyrbil – fördelar och nackdelar

Köpa begagnad hyrbil – fördelar och nackdelar

Trots lägre pris ryggar många undan inför tanken att köpa en begagnad hyrbil. Vem vill ha en bil som körts av fler personer än man kan räkna? Men är många personer bak ratten automatiskt lika med en sämre skött och mer sliten bil? Drömbilen för billigare än i dina drömmar Föreställ dig en bil av […]

Försäljningsrekord av begagnat under 2016 – trots svagt sista kvartal

Försäljningsrekord av begagnat under 2016 – trots svagt sista kvartal

Under 2016 sattes ett nytt försäljningsrekord av begagnade bilar. Totalt såldes 1 177 644 bilar – en ökning på 12 066 bilar jämfört med året innan. Samtidigt har försäljningstillväxten för 2016 mattats av och en negativ försäljningstrend gick att skönja under sista kvartalet. I hela sex län minskade försäljningen under 2016. Försäljningen av begagnade bilar […]

Vem ersätter Nico Rosberg?

Vem ersätter Nico Rosberg?

Janne Blomqvist går igenom förutsättningarna inför den förarplats hos Mercedes som ska fyllas efter Nico Rosbergs plötsliga avhopp.

Ny bevisning mot toppchefer i Saab

Ny bevisning mot toppchefer i Saab

Stora mängder mail utgör ny bevisning mot åtalade personer i gamla Saab Automobile.